Skip to main content

A-Harmonic Equations and the Dirac Operator


We show how -harmonic equations arise as components of Dirac systems. We generalize -harmonic equations to -Dirac equations. Removability theorems are proved for solutions to -Dirac equations.

1. Introduction

This paper explains how -harmonic equations arise from Dirac systems. Indeed the main purpose of this paper is to elucidate the connection between the theories of -harmonic functions and Dirac analysis. An -harmonic equation is a component of a Dirac system


This component is the scalar (real) part of the Dirac system, under appropriate identifications. Hence any real-valued solution to the Dirac system is an -harmonic function. As such, the class of -harmonic functions which are also solutions of the Dirac system are a special class of -harmonic functions. See Section 3 for a detailed discussion. As an application, we show that a result concerning removable singularities for -harmonic functions satisfying a Lipschitz condition or of bounded mean oscillation extends to Clifford valued solutions to corresponding Dirac equations. The result also holds for functions of a certain order of growth. This seems to be new even in the case of an -harmonic function.

In Section 2, we present preliminaries about Clifford algebra along with definitions and notations. In Section 3, we introduce -Dirac equations and show the correspondence with -harmonic equations. The Caccioppoli estimate for solutions to -Dirac equations appears in Section 4 and the removability theorems are in Section 5 along with references. For other recent work on nonlinear Dirac equations, see [16].

2. Preliminaries

We write for the real universal Clifford algebra over The Clifford algebra is generated over by the basis of reduced products


where is an orthonormal basis of with the relation We write for the identity. The dimension of is . We have an increasing tower The Clifford algebra is a graded algebra as , where are those elements whose reduced Clifford products have length

For , denotes the scalar part of , that is, the coefficient of the element .

Throughout, is a connected and open set with boundary . A Clifford-valued function can be written as where each is real-valued and are reduced products. The norm used here is given by This norm is submultiplicative, .

The Dirac operator used here is as follows:


Also Here is the Laplace operator which operates only on coefficients. A function is monogenic when

Throughout, is a cube in with volume . We write for the cube with the same center as and with sidelength times that of . For , we write for the space of Clifford-valued functions in whose coefficients belong to the usual space. Also, is the space of Clifford valued functions in whose coefficients as well as their first distributional derivatives are in . We also write for , where the intersection is over all compactly contained in We similarly write Moreover, we write for the space of monogenic functions in

Furthermore, we define the Dirac Sobolev space


The local space is similarly defined. Notice that if is monogenic, then if and only if Also it is immediate that

3. Correspondence and the -Dirac Equation

We first define the -harmonic equation. We define operators


Here is measurable for all , and is continuous for a.e. We assume the structure conditions with :


for some The exponent will represent this exponent throughout.

An -harmonic function, , is a weak solution to , when


for all with compact support.

See [7] for the theory of -harmonic equations.

To connect these equations with Dirac systems, we define the linear isomorphism by


It follows that for a real-valued function , we have , and for , we have


Next we define by


In this way, we see that (3.3) is equivalent to


This motivates the following definition for Dirac systems of higher-order Clifford valued functions. We use the Clifford conjugation The product defines a Clifford-valued inner product.

Moreover, the scalar part of this Clifford inner product is the usual inner product in , when and are identified as vectors. We continue to use the Clifford notation for this scalar product. This conjugation compensates for the minus sign in (3.5) and in higher-order Clifford products. Moreover, the conjugation can be incorporated into an integration by parts formula.

To this purpose (we are replacing with for convenience) we recast the structure equations above and define operators:


We assume that preserves the grading of the Clifford algebra. Here is measurable for all , and is continuous for a.e. We assume the structure conditions with :


for some

Definition 3.1.

A Clifford valued function , for is a weak solution to


if for all with compact support we have


Notice that when is the identity, then (3.13) is the Clifford Laplacian. Moreover these equations generalize the important case of the -Dirac equation:



These equations were introduced and their conformal invariance was studied in [8].

In the case of the -Dirac equation, , when , and , , are solutions to (3.13). Notice that a monogenic function is trivially a solution to (3.13) and if is a solution to (3.13), then so is for any monogenic function

In the case that is a real-valued function also implies that


where So in this case (3.13) can be identified with the two equations


Hence when is a function, (3.13) implies that is a harmonic field and locally there exists a harmonic function such that If is invertible, then Hence regularity of implies regularity of the solution . Notice that if , then , where

In general, -harmonic functions do not have such regularity. This suggests the study of the scalar part of the system equation (3.13) in general. Indeed a Caccioppoli estimate holds for solutions to the scalar part of (3.13). This is the topic of the next section.

Hence we see a special class of -harmonic functions, namely, real-valued solutions to the system (3.13). This class should have special properties.

On the other hand, results about -harmonic functions suggest possible properties of general solutions to (3.13). In this paper, we present one such extension, that of removable sets. The essential ingredient in the proof is the Caccioppoli estimate.

4. A Caccioppoli Estimate

Next is a Caccioppoli estimate for solutions to (3.13). This result appears in [9]. We give the short proof here for completeness.

Theorem 4.1.

Let be a solution to scalar part of (3.13) and , Then



Choose . Then Hence using (3.13) and (3.10),


Using Hölder's inequality and (3.11), we have


Corollary 4.2.

Suppose that is a solution to (3.13). Let be a cube with where . Then there is a constant , independent of , such that



Choose , , in and .

5. Removability

For monogenic functions with modulus of continuity , sets of -Hausdorff measure are removable [1]. For Hölder continuous analytic functions, see [10]. Sets satisfying a certain geometric condition related to Minkowski dimension are shown to be removable for -harmonic functions in Hölder and bounded mean oscillation classes in [11]. In the case of Hölder continuity, this was sharped in [12] to a precise condition for removable sets for -harmonic functions in terms of Hausdorff dimension.

We show here that sets satisfying a generalized Minkowski-type inequality, similar to that in [11], are removable for solutions to the -Dirac equation which satisfy a certain oscillation condition. The following definition is motivated by the fact that real-valued functions satisfying various regularity properties are characterized by this definition. We explain below.

Definition 5.1.

Assume that , and that

We say that is of -oscillation in when


The infimum over monogenic functions is natural since they are trivially solutions to an -Dirac equation just as constants are solutions to an -harmonic equation. If is a function and , then (5.1) is equivalent to the usual definition of the bounded mean oscillation when and (5.1) is equivalent to the usual local Lipschitz condition when [13]. Moreover, at least when is a solution to an -harmonic equation, (5.1) is equivalent to a local order of growth condition when ; see [9, 14]. In these cases, the supremum is finite if we choose to be the average value of the function over the cube . It is easy to see that in condition (5.1) the expansion factor "2" can be replaced by any factor greater than 1.

If the coefficients of an -Dirac solution are of bounded mean oscillation, local Hölder continuous, or of a certain local order of growth, then is in an appropriate oscillation class; see [9].

Notice that monogenic functions satisfy (5.1) just as the space of constants is a subspace of the bounded mean oscillation and Lipschitz spaces of real-valued functions.

We remark that it follows from Hölder's inequality that if and if is of -oscillation, then is of -oscillation.

The following lemma shows that Definition 5.1 is independent of the expansion factor of the cube.

Lemma 5.2.

Suppose that , a.e., , and If





If , then the implication is immediate. Assume Let be a cube with Dyadically subdivide into a finite number of subcubes with Then for all . Moreover,


We use a Whitney decomposition of . The decomposition consists of closed dyadic cubes with disjoint interiors which satisfy



(c) when is not empty.

Here is the Euclidean distance between and the boundary of ; see [15].

We use the following definition. If and , then we define the -inflation of as


We now state the removability result.

Theorem 5.3.

Let be a relatively closed subset of . Suppose that has distributional first derivatives in , is a solution to the scalar part of the -Dirac equation (3.13) in , and is of -oscillation in . If for each compact subset of


then extends to a solution of the A-Dirac equation in .


Let be a cube in the Whitney decomposition of . Using the Caccioppoli estimate and the -oscillation condition, we have


Here . Since the problem is local (use a partition of unity), we show that (3.13) holds whenever with and sufficiently small. Choose and let Then is a compact subset of . Also let be those cubes in the Whitney decomposition of which meet Notice that each cube lies in Let First, since , it follows that ; see [11]. Also since using (5.6) and (5.7), we obtain



Next let and assume that . Also let be those cubes with

Consider the scalar functions


Thus each , is Lipschitz, equal to on and as such with compact support. Hence


Since is a solution in ,

Also we have


Now there exists a constant such that Hence using Hölder's inequality,


Next using (4.4), the above is


Now for is bounded above and below by a multiple of and for Hence


Since and as it follows that as

Next again using Hölder's inequality,


Since and as , we have that as Hence .


  1. Abreu-Blaya R, Bory-Reyes J, Peña-Peña D: Jump problem and removable singularities for monogenic functions. The Journal of Geometric Analysis 2007, 17(1):1–13. 10.1007/s00039-006-0585-4

    Article  MathSciNet  MATH  Google Scholar 

  2. Chen Q, Jost J, Li J, Wang G: Dirac-harmonic maps. Mathematische Zeitschrift 2006, 254(2):409–432. 10.1007/s00209-006-0961-7

    Article  MathSciNet  MATH  Google Scholar 

  3. Chen Q, Jost J, Li J, Wang G: Regularity theorems and energy identities for Dirac-harmonic maps. Mathematische Zeitschrift 2005, 251(1):61–84. 10.1007/s00209-005-0788-7

    Article  MathSciNet  MATH  Google Scholar 

  4. Chen Q, Jost J, Wang G: Nonlinear Dirac equations on Riemann surfaces. Annals of Global Analysis and Geometry 2008, 33(3):253–270. 10.1007/s10455-007-9084-6

    Article  MathSciNet  MATH  Google Scholar 

  5. Wang C: A remark on nonlinear Dirac equations. preprint preprint

  6. Wang C, Xu D: Regularity of Dirac-harmonic maps. International Mathematics Research Notices 2009, (20):3759–3792.

  7. Heinonen J, Kilpeläinen T, Martio O: Nonlinear Potential Theory of Degenerate Elliptic Equations, Oxford Mathematical Monographs. Oxford University Press, New York, NY, USA; 1993:vi+363.

    Google Scholar 

  8. Nolder CA, Ryan J: -Dirac operators. Advances in Applied Clifford Algebra 2009, 19(2):391–402. 10.1007/s00006-009-0162-7

    Article  MathSciNet  MATH  Google Scholar 

  9. Nolder CA: Nonlinear -Dirac equations. to appear in Advances in Applied Clifford Algebra to appear in Advances in Applied Clifford Algebra

  10. Kaufman R, Wu JM: Removable singularities for analytic or subharmonic functions. Arkiv för Matematik 1980, 18(1):107–116. 10.1007/BF02384684

    Article  MathSciNet  MATH  Google Scholar 

  11. Koskela P, Martio O: Removability theorems for solutions of degenerate elliptic partial differential equations. Arkiv för Matematik 1993, 31(2):339–353. 10.1007/BF02559490

    Article  MathSciNet  MATH  Google Scholar 

  12. Kilpeläinen T, Zhong X: Removable sets for continuous solutions of quasilinear elliptic equations. Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society 2002, 130(6):1681–1688. 10.1090/S0002-9939-01-06237-2

    Article  MathSciNet  MATH  Google Scholar 

  13. Meyers NG: Mean oscillation over cubes and Hölder continuity. Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society 1964, 15: 717–721.

    MathSciNet  MATH  Google Scholar 

  14. Langmeyer N: The quasihyperbolic metric, growth, and John domains. Annales Academiæ Scientiarium Fennicæ. Mathematica 1998, 23(1):205–224.

    MathSciNet  MATH  Google Scholar 

  15. Stein EM: Singular Integrals and Differentiability Properties of Functions, Princeton Mathematical Series, no. 30. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ, USA; 1970:xiv+290.

    Google Scholar 

Download references

Author information

Authors and Affiliations


Corresponding author

Correspondence to CraigA Nolder.

Rights and permissions

Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 International License (, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Nolder, C. A-Harmonic Equations and the Dirac Operator. J Inequal Appl 2010, 124018 (2010).

Download citation

  • Received:

  • Accepted:

  • Published:

  • DOI:


  • Weak Solution
  • Harmonic Function
  • Dirac Equation
  • Dirac Operator
  • Clifford Algebra